Skip to search boxSkip to navigationSkip to main content

Establishing an effective environmental baseline for offshore CCS

  • Steve Widdicombe(corresponding author)
    ,
  • Veerle A.I. Huvenne
    ,
  • James Strong
    ,
  • Jerry Blackford
    ,
  • Gavin Tilstone
*Corresponding author for this work
  • Plymouth Marine Laboratory
    ,
  • National Oceanography Centre Southampton
Research Output:
Contribution to conference
Paper
Research
Peer-review

Abstract

The proposed storage of CO2 in sub-seabed geological reservoirs, known as Carbon dioxide Capture and Storage (CCS), could make a practical and significant contribution to reducing atmospheric CO2 emissions thereby alleviating environmental and ecological damage due to climate change and ocean acidification. However, before any new marine activity is conducted, it is standard procedure for any environmental risks potentially posed by that activity to be considered. In particular, understanding what is ‘natural’ or ‘normal’ for an area is essential when looking to establish criteria against which potential environmental impacts can be identified, monitored and quantified. To that end, all offshore CCS projects would benefit from constructing an effective environmental baseline prior to the start of storage. However, due to the large spatial extent of storage complexes and the expectation that storage of the CO2 will be permanent, there are a number of financial, logistical and methodological issues associated with constructing such baselines. Firstly, sub-seabed storage complexes are sizeable structures. Whilst individual leakage events themselves are likely to be rare and have a small spatial impact, it might be considered that anywhere above the storage complex could potentially be the location of a leakage event. In reality very few areas will be at any risk from leakage but for the sake of public reassurance and in line with the precautionary principle, constructing an environmental baseline which covered the whole complex footprint would be prudent. However, assessing such large areas does raise certain challenges. The marine environment in general is highly spatially variable in terms of its physical, chemical and biological makeup with scales of variability ranging from the sub-metre scale corresponding to benthic patchiness, to dynamic boundaries between water masses of different origins, which may stretch for many kilometres. Consequently, the large area of marine environment that sits above a CCS reservoir will inevitably contain a mosaic of different seabed habitats and biological communities. It will also consist of varying water masses and pelagic biomes. This large spatial extent and high level of spatial variability, raises problems of affordability when attempting to construct the type of environmental baseline required to comprehensively assess any potential environmental risks associated with CCS activities. In addition to the problems associated with assessing environmental heterogeneity over large spatial scales, described above, the marine environment also displays high levels of temporal variability. This is particularly relevant to many of the environmental parameters that may be directly used to identify and monitor CO2 leakage events, such as changes in carbonate chemistry parameters which can undergo large and rapid fluctuations as a result of naturally occurring biological and physical processes. In addition to shorter term fluctuations, the marine environment is being exposed to longer-term changes in environmental conditions driven by man-made pressures such as climate change and changes in human activities (e.g. fishing, resource extraction, pollution). These gradual, chronic changes are especially important when considering the typical life-span of a CCS project. With the intention of storing CO2 permanently it is essential that future long-term changes in environmental conditions are understood and such changes are not falsely attributed to CCS activities. All of this means that collecting sufficient amounts of observational data to adequately account for tidal, seasonal, annual and decadal trends and cycles, prior to starting any CCS activities would be impractical using traditional methods and would delay the rapid deployment of CCS projects, thus reducing this technology’s potential contribution to reducing CO2 emissions. To meet the challenges of constructing effective environmental baselines that adequately account for large spatial and temporal scales, and thereby provide public reassurance that any potential risks are both identified and managed, new approaches in baseline data collection and analysis are needed. In this paper we illustrate a generic framework that combines some new and existing approaches and opportunities to extend environmental baselines through time and expand their spatial coverage. In doing so we illustrate how baseline data can be collected in a cost-effective and appropriate manner.

Research Output Information

Output type

Research Output:
Contribution to conference
Paper
Research
Peer-review

Original language

English

Publication milestones

  • Published - 2018

Publication status

Published - 2018

Publication IDs

  • Scopus: 85105489905

Related Event

Title

14th International Conference on Greenhouse Gas Control Technologies, GHGT 2018

Event type

Conference

Date

21/10/2018 - 25/10/2018

Location

MelbourneAustralia

Publication metrics

Metrics

SciVal
FWCI
0.56
Scopus
citations

PlumX

Captures
8
Citation count
1

Sustainable Development Goals

  • SDG 13 - Climate Action
    SDG 13 Climate Action
  • SDG 14 - Life Below Water
    SDG 14 Life Below Water